News

Trinity Sunday 2026

On Trinity Sunday this year, we celebrated with a series of reflections, mostly in poetry, on the nature of the Trinity and Its divine dance of love.

If you missed the service, you can watch it on YouTube here.

If you’d like to spend some more time meditating on these readings, or look for something you missed on Sunday, you can find all of them below:

Richard Rohr | Michael Coffey | Godfrey Rust | Slats Toole | Rachael Keefe

Fr. Richard Rohr, “The Mystery of the Trinity”

Source: Center for Action and Contemplation blog

The notion of God as Trinity is the foundation of all Christian thought, and yet it never has been—not truly! Our dualistic minds largely shelved the whole thing because we simply couldn’t understand it. Most Christians do not consciously deny the Trinity, but as Karl Rahner wrote, “We must be willing to admit that, should the doctrine of the Trinity have to be dropped as false, the major part of religious literature could well remain virtually unchanged.” What a sad statement on our fundamental understanding of God!

The Trinity reveals God more as a verb than a noun, but we rarely speak about God that way in either our preaching or our prayers. God is three “relations,” which itself is mind-boggling for most believers. Yet that clarification opens up an honest notion of God as Mystery who can never be fully comprehended with our rational minds. God is dynamic—a verb rather than a static name. God is Interbeing itself, and never an isolated deity that can be captured by our mind.

Christians believe that God is formlessness (the Father), God is form (the Son), and God is the very living and loving energy between those two (the Holy Spirit). The three do not cancel one another out. Instead, they do exactly the opposite. Recognizing the Trinity as relationship itself opens conversations with the world of science. This surprising insight names everything correctly at the core—from atoms, to ecosystems, to galaxies.

The shape of God is the shape of everything in the universe! Everything is in relationship and nothing stands alone. The doctrine of the Trinity defeats the dualistic mind and invites us into nondual, holistic consciousness. It replaces the argumentative principle of two with the dynamic principle of three. It brings us inside the wonderfully open space of “not one, but not two either.” Sit stunned with that for a few moments.

The most ancient and solid theology of the Trinity proceeds from the Cappadocian Fathers of the third and fourth centuries and is then adopted by later Councils of the Church. Trinitarian theology says that God is a “circular” rotation of total outpouring and perfect receiving among three intimate partners. Historically, most of us, except for mystics, preferred the pyramid model with God the Father at the top, which then got imitated and promoted all the way down! This is no exaggeration.

As Catherine LaCugna presented in her monumental study of the Trinity, any notion of God as not giving, not outpouring, not self-surrendering, not totally loving is a theological impossibility and absurdity. God only and always loves. You cannot reverse, slow, or limit an overflowing waterwheel of divine compassion and mercy and a love stronger than death. It goes in only one, constant, eternal direction—toward ever more abundant and creative life! This is the universe from atoms to galaxies.

^ Back to top

The Rev. Michael Coffey, “Trinity is a Poem”

Source: Rev. Coffey’s blog

Trinity is a poem uttered free verse as cosmic love gift
sending sound waves through earth to hurl speech
into the ionosphere stirring radio waves to hum

Trinity is a synchronistic dream we and God have
nightly about the interface of human and divine
the matrix of connections between holy and common

Trinity is a syncopated counterpoint of melody lines
referencing each other and making music as sonorous
as whales and pulsars and seismic waves all held in tension

then someone inscribed the free utterance in indelible ink
and someone analyzed the shared dream with Freudian precision
and someone forced the messy melodies smooth in straight time

behold: just when they think they finished the job and
brush the dust of such work off their hands and rest
Trinity dances out the door and finds willing partners to twirl

^ Back to top

Godfrey Rust, “Trialogue”

Source: Rust’s website

The Gods that are Three-in-One said
to the God that is One-in-Three
We must be parted for a time,
me from me from me;


but one of the One-in-Three said
to the Gods that are Three-in-One
What is to become of us
when all of this is done?

For a God that is man will know of things
that a God should never know
and will eat of the tree of knowledge
where the fruit of despair will grow.


Then the God that is the Father said
to the God that is the Son
You know I am with you always
for you and I are One

but the God that is man must somehow know
that the God that is God may not be,
so I must hide myself enough
to disbelieve in me;


and the God that was now a dying man
cried out all-knowingly
my God my God my God
why have I forsaken me?

^ Back to top

Slats Toole, “I Praise an Ever-Shifting God”

Source now lost to time…

I praise an ever-shifting God,
who slips through the fingers of any hand that tries to grasp it and pin it down.
My God is found in silver crosses and pipe organs,
in long robes and candles--
and my God is found in drums and clapping and dancing and loud “Amen!”s.
My God forgives debts, trespasses and sins,
whether you believe in One God or God the Father Almighty.
My God sings through raised soft palates
and speaks in tongues.
My God penetrates the words of the great theologians,
and lifts up the voice of the testimony,
and sparks the questions of the doubting.

I worship the God of the mountains; majestic, eternal, unchanging.
I worship the God of the sea; unfathomable, unknowable, unpredictable.
I worship the God of the desert; harsh, purifying, searching.
I worship the God of the city; vibrant, busy, colorful.
I worship the God of the home; comforting, intimate, warm.
I worship a human God, who laughs and weeps as all humanity does.
I worship a separate God, who sees what I cannot.

And I sing to a God that left the church’s doors
to weave in and out of all the world
to appear in blue jeans
and on cardboard signs begging for money
a God that found its way into the synagogues, the mosques, the temples, the yoga classes,
who appears to the churchfolk through the voice of the atheist
who finds a strain of love in the world
and wraps itself around it, multiplying its light,
for my God is everything and anything that is based in love.

My God dances away from my reaching fingertips
but is somehow in my hand.
And I spend my life trying to glimpse it,
only to hear it laugh and say, “I am right here! Open your eyes!”

If your God is an idea you can easily grasp,
a one-gendered, unconfusing, comprehensible idea that seems to hold much power in that simplicity,
I would like to challenge our Gods to a duel.
For how could my big God lose against your tiny one?
For if we believe God is all-powerful,
how dare we restrict God to one image?

Is it not the gravest sin to limit this lively, playful, mysterious, abundant, loving thing we call God?

^ Back to top

The Rev. Dr. Rachael Keefe, “A Poem for Trinity Sunday”

Source: Rev. Dr. Keefe’s former blog

Holy One,

I contemplate the sacred dance
and wonder when I will learn the steps
steps of peace, healing, hope
not just for a few
for all who yearn for freedom

You created all that is
as the Spirit hovered
and the Word spoke
and Wisdom beaconed
and the whole of You delighted in Creation


now we are tangled up in the limits of our language
trying to make You three and one
when You are always so much more
a Sacred Mystery breathing Life
and stirring visions

our lips have been burned clean
our sins have been blotted out
yet we remain outside your realm
(with guns in hand and fear holding us still)
which is close enough to reach
and too far for us to embody
because we have yet to believe
that which has always been:

Your love for us never ends
we can refuse to see it or claim it
we can deny it and avoid it
yet, we cannot separate ourselves from Love

what if the day is coming when our world is shaken
by the power of your glory
shaken so hard that we fall from doubt and disbelief
fear and hatred
apathy and ambivalence
into the truth of your delight in us?

what if we hover with the Spirit over Creation’s waters
and see only Love reflecting
an invitation to learn the steps of the dance
right now?


what if we hear the Word that sears our lips
and speak only grace, hope, and joy
echoing the song you’ve been singing from Earth’s beginning
longing for us to listen?

what if we follow Wisdom’s way
and create justice and offer mercy
until the world finds its rhythm
without violence
without destruction
without division?

God-in-Community,
may you remain patient with humanity
remain steadfast
until we claim your Love
share your Love
embody your Love

continue to shower us with forgiveness
until we know the truth
of your claim on us
and have the courage
to see you
in ourselves
in each other
in the whole of Creation


teach us to seek justice for all people
to love with your patience and compassion
and rely on You when we encounter the limits
of our bodies
of our minds
of our human ways

during this Pentecost season
blow through our lives
and set our holy heads on fire
that we may be the Church-Made-New
born again
born from above
born anew

Amen.

^ Back to top

Lent & Easter Events

We have a number of gatherings available as we journey through the Lenten season toward Holy Week and Easter. We will be focusing on the meaning of Holy Communion throughout the season. All are welcome to join us at any or all of these events!

Preparation

Our annual Mardi Gras Pancake Dinner at 5pm on February 17th in Truesdale Hall. Join us for food, fellowship, and a final preparation for the Lenten season.

The Sanctuary will be open for prayer all day on Ash Wednesday, February 18th. There will be materials available near the altar to offer inspiration.

We will be offering ashes-to-go at the Scott St. door from 12pm to 2pm. Stop by on your lunch break—you don’t even have to leave your car if it’s cold! You are also welcome to attend the worship service at 7pm at Mayville UMC (89 S Erie St).

Bible Study

We have two Bible studies available for you during this Lenten season:

Here at Hurlbut, we will be gathering on Tuesdays at 6:15pm for a study called This Holy Mystery. We will be discussing the meaning of Holy Communion in our United Methodist tradition, alongside the themes of the sermon series for each week. The study gathers in Truesdale Hall and on Zoom.

Several of our local United Methodist churches are also gathering together for a cooperative study on Wednesdays at 3:30pm (except Ash Wednesday). This study is called The Power of Knowing God and examines what it means to truly know God and be changed by that relationship. Sessions will be taught by Tyler Nelson of Ripley and Watts Flats UMCs and will take place at Westfield UMC (101 E Main St).

Both studies will run about an hour per session. You need not have attended a previous session to join. All are welcome!

Holy Week

We will gather at 7pm on Maundy Thursday, April 2nd, for Holy Communion as we enter the Great Three Days commemorating Christ’s passion & death.

Immediately following the service, our annual Prayer Vigil begins. You may sign up for an hour to pray at the church or at home, as we watch and wait with Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane.

The prayer vigil will end with our 7pm Good Friday service on April 3rd. This year, we will be listening to the full account of the passion as narrated by John. The story will be accompanied by music and visual art and will end in darkness.

Easter

All are invited to dress warm and gather with us at Palestine Park for our Easter Sunrise Vigil. We will gather at 7am on April 5th around the firepit (I promise there will actually be fire this year) to hear the history of God’s saving deeds, culminating in this great moment of triumphant love.

And, as always, our usual morning worship service at 10:45am will feature Easter hymns, festive flowers, and Holy Communion as we celebrate the Resurrection.

Join Us for Advent & Christmas!

We have a ton of stuff going on this year during Advent and Christmas. We’d love for you to join us at any or all of these events!

Preparation

We have two events to help us prepare our church and our hearts for the season of Advent and the coming of Christ.

Hanging of the Greens will take place immediately after worship on the First Sunday of Advent, November 30th. A make-your-own sub sandwich bar will be provided for lunch, and you can stop to eat any time before, during, or after helping us decorate the building for Christmas.

If you’d like, you can stick around after decorating to watch the Bills game together in Truesdale. Bring a snack to share, or a dessert for lunch!

Our annual 24-Hour Prayer Vigil will take place the following weekend, beginning at 3pm on Friday, December 5th and ending at 3pm the next day.

Worship

Our regular worship service will continue as usual through the season of Advent. We gather at 10:45am in the Sanctuary and online, and we serve Communion every week.

Our annual Christmas Pageant will be on the Third Sunday of Advent, December 14th, during worship.

Our annual Lessons & Carols service will be the following week, December 21st, during worship.

All are welcome to celebrate the birth of Christ with us on Christmas Eve at our 7pm Candlelight Christmas Service.

Bible Study

Just like last year, several of our local United Methodist churches are gathering together for a cooperative Advent Bible Study! The study guide we’ll be using is called simply “Advent,” and it’s by Derwin Gray. Susan Hardy, our District Lay Leader, is teaching.

The study will gather at Mayville UMC (81 S Erie St.) from 2 to 3pm on Mondays from November 24th through December 22nd. You need not have attended a previous session to join. All are welcome!

Music

As mentioned above, our Lessons & Carols service will be on the Fourth Sunday of Advent (the 21st) during worship.

We also have two Christmas concerts being planned, one around the middle of Advent, and one near the end of Christmastide. Stay tuned for details!

Our It’s Still Christmas Concert will feature John Cross and the big band, as well as a few of Hurlbut’s own musicians. The tentative date is January 3rd.

Our Wesleyan Heritage

This summer, our Senior Pastor went with a group of young United Methodist clergy to England for a Wesley Heritage Tour. Our October sermon series was based on this trip, and we thought you might want to see some photos relevant to the topics covered in those sermons:

Week 1: Epworth & the Roots of Methodism

The Epworth Market Cross

The Epworth Market Cross on a cloudy day. The streets dominate the photo, with a few buildings behind. The stone marker for the crossing is visible in the distance.

Many English towns organised the market in the shape of a cross, as a reminder to conduct one’s business with Christian ethics.

Many included a stone marker, with a small raised platform, on one corner. John Wesley preached from the one here in Epworth on numerous occasions.

You can see the marker in the center of the photo, covered in crocheted red poppies in honour of VJ Day. Poppies are associated with veterans in the UK because of the poppies that grew on Flanders Fields after WWI.

The Old Rectory

The rector, or head priest, of the Epworth parish church lived at this rectory. During the early part of John’s life, that rector was his father, Samuel Wesley.

When John was only 5 years old, the previous building’s thatched roof caught fire and burned almost entirely to the ground. John barely survived when a bystander saw him in the upstairs window and rescued him.

Samuel was convinced it was a parishioner who’d lit the fire. The parish would have paid for a modest new home, but Samuel went into debt to rebuild it in brick.

The Grave of Samuel Wesley

John’s father was buried right outside the church he served for forty years.

When Samuel’s successor refused to allow John to preach inside the church because he was both too popular and too “enthusiastic”—i.e., too emotional—John stood on top of his father’s grave that evening and preached from there.

Visitors can no longer stand on top of the grave, but they do provide a chair for photos.

Week 2: Oxford & the Holy Club

The University Church at Oxford

The University Church of St. Mary the Virgin serves the entire community of Oxford University, all its colleges, and the surrounding city.

During his ministry, John Wesley preached three challenging sermons to the students and professors of his time. In one, he charged the congregation to be “altogether Christians,” rather than “Almost Christians.”

After the third sermon criticised the spiritual apathy of the university community, he was never asked to preach there again.

Christ Church Cathedral

John and Charles Wesley were both students at Christ Church, one of the many colleges that make up Oxford University.

The college church is the city’s cathedral (the seat of the bishop) and has been associated with high-church Anglicanism since before the Wesleys’ time.

Both Wesleys were ordained as priests of the Church of England in this cathedral, in 1728 (John) and 1735 (Charles).

Lincoln College, Oxford

After completing his studies, John was elected a fellow of Lincoln College. As a fellow, he was responsible for research and teaching, and he lived on the grounds.

One of the offices in the College has been set up to mimic what Wesley’s study might have looked like during his time there. A bust on the outside wall marks the space.

It was in his Oxford study that John convened the meetings of the “Holy Club” his brother had started not long before.

Week 3: Field Preaching in Bristol

Hanham Mount

Originally just a simple hill, this grassy spot in Bristol was the birth of Methodist field preaching.

George Whitfield, an early Calvinist Methodist, invited John to join him in preaching to the coal workers in the area who did not have easy access to church life. At first, John “could not reconcile [him]self to this strange way of preaching,” but it soon became an integral part of the Methodist movement.

Set on the current stone pulpit is the simplified version of John’s words, “I look upon all the world as my parish.”

The New Room

As the Methodist movement grew, the need for a home base of sorts grew as well. This “New Room” in Bristol was that home base.

Though not a church, this meeting house saw many Methodist gatherings, and preachers stayed in the bedrooms upstairs while working from the Bristol circuit. From the windows in the dining room, John could look down and listen to preachers in training.

Preachers staying here were expected to gather daily for regular worship and communal meals, in order to build deep relationships with one another and keep them spiritually grounded.

Charles Wesley’s Home

From 1749 to 1771, Charles Wesley lived in this Bristol townhouse.

The home is kept up today as a museum containing artefacts related to Charles and his family, such as the harpsichord in the family music room, or his desk in the attic.

His son, Samuel Wesley, named for John and Charles’ father, was born here. The younger Samuel became a prolific composer and organist, and was at times called “the English Mozart.” His own son Samuel Sebastian Wesley became a composer as well, and some of his tunes are in our hymnal to this day.

Week 4: London & Aldersgate Street

Aldersgate Street

Outside the London Museum stands a flame-shaped monument marking the moment that John Wesley experienced his “heart strangely warmed.”

It’s uncertain exactly where the house on Aldersgate Street was, but on May 24, 1738, just three days after his brother had his own similar experience, John went to a prayer meeting.

As they read from Luther’s Preface to Romans, John suddenly felt God’s grace more personally and concretely than he ever had. He later said it almost felt like he hadn’t been Christian at all until then.

City Road Chapel

The first actual Methodist house of worship was built on the site of an old cannon foundry in London.

It still serves as an active Methodist Church. Wesley’s Chapel is currently led by its first female Superintendent Minister, the Revd Dr Jennifer Smith, though women have preached there since 1926.

Beneath the church is a museum of artefacts from Methodist history all over the world. John Wesley is buried in the small garden behind the chapel, and his mother Susanna is buried in the cemetery across the street.

John Wesley’s Home

For the last several years of his life, John Wesley lived in the home within the courtyard of the City Road Chapel.

The window of his prayer closet overlooked the chapel building, and one can imagine him praying for the many Methodists who saw this as their home.

John continued to preach regularly until the last year of his life. After that his health began to fail—and yet he was out preaching just days before his death. On his deathbed, his friends were with him singing. His last words were, “The best of all is, God is with us.”

Fund our Mission to Guatemala!

19 workers from 3 United Methodist churches will be going to Guatemala this July, and two of them are from our own church family!

The mission trip is sponsored by Catalyst Resources International, and will involve building three homes for families in need. Each church is teaming up to raise the $5700 needed to build and furnish each house, and there are two ways you can help!

On Tuesday, June 10th, we’ll have a Taco Tuesday fundraiser in Truesdale Hall. You can stop by any time from 5–7pm to eat tacos and make a donation toward the mission fund.

Call the church office (716-357-4045) by June 3rd to let us know you’re coming! RSVPs aren’t required, but they’ll help us make sure we have enough taco supplies.

You can also support the mission trip by sponsoring Grant’s bike ride to Cincinnati in June! Consider sponsoring him by the mile, or contributing a flat amount toward the mission. To do so, just include “Guatemala” on the memo line of your check, or on an envelope containing your cash donation.

Schedule for Lent 2025

A crown of thornes made of sticks and dried palm leaves lies flat on a purple brocade cloth.

The Lenten season is upon us once more. As we prepare to reflect on our lives and our work as people of God, take a moment to mark your calendars for these special worship and fellowship opportunities:

Mardi Gras Pancake Dinner: March 4 – 5 pm – Truesdale Hall
Join us for our annual pancake dinner to celebrate the final day of the Epiphany season. We’ll be “burying the Alleluia,” so bring your creative spirit to help us colour Alleluia pages for Easter morning.

Ashes-to-Go: March 5 – 12 pm – Scott St. Entrance
No time for a full worship service this year? Stop by the Scott St. side door on your lunch break, from noon to 2 pm, to receive your ashes for the start of Lent. The Sanctuary will be open all day as well—spend as long as you like in meditation and prayer for Ash Wednesday.

Palm Sunday: April 13 – 10:45 am – Sanctuary
Shout Hosanna and wave some palms with us as we celebrate Jesus’ procession into Jerusalem and prepare our hearts for the events of Holy Week.

Maundy Thursday Communion: April 17 – 7 pm – Sanctuary
We will begin the Great Three Days with a service of Taizé-style music and Holy Communion. As always, all are welcome at this open table.

All-Night Prayer Vigil: April 17–18 – Sanctuary or at home
As he prayed in the garden, Jesus asked his disciples to stay awake with him. From the close of Maundy Thursday worship to the beginning of the Good Friday service, we will keep watch in that spirit. You can sign up for an hour of the vigil on the sheet in Truesdale Hall, and you can pray from the church or from home. There will be prayer materials available in the Sanctuary to assist you.

Good Friday Tenebrae: April 18 – 7 pm – Sanctuary
We will mark the crucifixion and death of our Lord with a service of darkness (tenebrae) based on the Seven Last Words. You are invited to join us for music and reflection on this holy day.

Easter Sunrise Vigil: April 20 – 7 am – Palestine Park (by the lake)
Dress warm and join us at the lake to celebrate the first service of Easter! We will be using a shortened form of the Easter Vigil service, which includes lighting the Paschal fire and Christ Candle, reading the history of salvation through the Hebrew Scriptures, and a reading of the Resurrection story. We’ll have breakfast at the church at the end!

Easter Morning Worship: April 20 – 10:45 am – Sanctuary
We’ll be in the Sanctuary at our usual time to celebrate the Resurrection with music, flowers, and Holy Communion. Join us as we give thanks to our Risen Lord!

CA Wildfires: How to Help

We watch with worry and grief as wildfires continue to rage in the LA area, and our hearts go out to our fellow United Methodists and others facing evacuations and loss.

If you are looking for ways to help those impacted the fires, we encourage you to donate through the United Methodist Committee on Relief. Through UMCOR, we as a denomination are often first on the ground in the midst of natural disasters, wars, and other crises. UMCOR works with local partners both in the States and abroad to best meet the needs of the communities they serve.

The overhead costs for UMCOR are funded in full by our (and others’) apportionments so that every dollar you donate goes directly to help folks on the ground.

UMCOR Donation Info

Give online: Select “USDR-California Wildfires” in the dropdown
Give through Hurlbut: Designate cash or check to Advance #901670 – California

Chautauqua’s UM House is Hiring!

Photo of the front lawn of the United Methodist House. Large trees stand between the viewer and the large House porch.

Each summer, the denominational houses of the Chautauqua Institution host numerous visitors to the grounds. The United Methodist House is currently seeking applicants to serve as Hosts for the House, beginning in the summer of 2026.

If you feel you have a gift for organisation, administration, and hospitality, we encourage you to consider applying by filling out the application form and submitting the required materials by December 31st.

Couples are strongly encouraged to apply, rather than individuals, as the job requires the time and energy of two people. Applicants should be able to commit to at least three summers of hosting (2026–2028), and will ideally have 1–2 weeks available in the summer of 2025 for training with the outgoing Hosts.

If you have any questions about the application, you can email Rev. Rachel.

Safe Haven Congregation

Hurlbut Church is now a Safe Haven Congregation. This means the Hurlbut community has committed to remaining in the United Methodist Church and offer RADICAL HOSPITALITY to anyone whose church closes or has chosen to disaffiliate or close. Regardless of our theological leaning, as United Methodists, we are all encouraged to follow the example in Acts 2 of the community of Jesus’ followers caring for each other – a diverse community that is ready to receive unity as a gift from God.

Logo of Safe Haven Congregations. The graphic is a light navy blue circle in which is outlined a lighthouse on a cliff beside the ocean. The logo reads, "Safe Haven Congregation. A place of hope, healing, and wholeness."

Safe Haven Congregations will:

  1. Provide a welcoming place to belong during this time of grief and transition, which might be for just a season or for a lifetime. This includes a safe space with caring relationships, listening hearts, and unconditional love within a congregation that is confident it is remaining in The United Methodist Church.
    1. Provide all forms of pastoral and laity-driven care.
    2. This may also include providing physical space for “Remnant” groups to gather as they consider what it looks like to stay together.
  2. Offer ministry opportunities in which to engage – or not. There will be no pressure.
    1. Worship: Providing worship opportunities, whether online or in person. These services will intentionally engage and welcome new people into their midst. They will also include the sacraments of communion and baptism.
    2. Discipleship: Creating space to learn and grow through small group gatherings, Bible studies, and prayer opportunities.
    3. Mission: Inviting fellow United Methodists into opportunities to serve through hands-on ministries. These might include anything that involves making a difference and sharing the love of God with others.
  3. Organize local Remaining UMC groups by proactively finding and connecting with individuals and groups displaced by disaffiliating churches.
  4. Connect individuals or groups with Conference and District resources to help them discern their next steps as they consider a new church home.

Safe Haven Congregations will be there for you during this transition, whether you are an individual or a group of people who have become displaced or churchless because of closing or disaffiliation. As you consider what is next, specific pathways you may choose will continue to emerge as the Conference, Districts, and local churches come together to be The Connection at its best.

Summer Worship!

Don’t forget, Hurlbut Memorial Community United Methodist Church provides an 8:30 am Sunday communion service every week during the Summer Assembly season.

We offer Communion, community, reflection, and will be finished in time to get you to your favorite denominational house service.

Join us in the Sanctuary, on our Facebook page via Facebook Live
on our YouTube Channel,
or right here on our website!